This can result in 18 months in prison and a fine of up to $10,000. For a single fake ID, a person can be charged with a crime of the fourth degree. The exact punishment for a conviction of making fake IDs depends on the number of false documents one is proved to have made or sold. What Are the Penalties for Making Fake IDs in NJ? Penalties can range from as little as 18 months to as much as 10 years in prison. 2C:21-17.3, Trafficking in Personal Identifying Information of Another. New Jersey criminalizes making fake IDs under N.J.S.A. The same is true of those who make, sell, or otherwise distribute unauthorized IDs. A person caught with a fake ID in New Jersey could face serious trouble.